philosophy meta-forum

Gender differences in journal submissions/acceptances

Patricia

220 day(s) ago

I was very impressed with these new data about gender differences in submissions and acceptances at journals:

http://jonathanweisberg.org/post/A%20Look%20at%20the%20APA-BPA%20Data/

Definitely worth taking a look.

Miriam

220 day(s) ago

quick summary?

Evelyn

220 day(s) ago

Weird things I noticed that have nothing to do with women and journals.

1) It seems to be harder to get into "Philosophical Quarterly" (3.3%!) than into "Mind" (5%)

2) The Canadian Journal of Philosophy has a bizarrely high acceptance rate for a generalist journal (I say bizarre because I think specialist journals, especially Ancient ones like Ancient Philosophy and OSAP seem to have high acceptance rates, the submissions are too low and I think Ancient philosophy is very self selecting,) like 16.6%

Thoughts?

Susanne

220 day(s) ago

I was very impressed with these new data about gender differences in submissions and acceptances at journals:

http://jonathanweisberg.org/post/A%20Look%20at%20the%20APA-BPA%20Data/

Definitely worth taking a look.

Patricia

Bottom line: editors choose whom to publish. and they favour women.

Take home point: only submit to triple-blind journal (i"m a man, despite the psudonym)

Ruwen

219 day(s) ago

Some highlights from this new data set:

- Across a broad range of journals, the acceptance rate is actually *higher* for women.

- The comparatively lower rate of publication for women is not due to a lower acceptance rate but rather to a lower number of submissions.

- Although the acceptance rate is higher for women overall, there is no gender difference in the acceptance rate at journals that use strict blind review.

Noam

219 day(s) ago

Women can be good logical geographers but they don't discover new places very often.

Bertolt

218 day(s) ago

This is not surprising, but it is depressing.

Georg

215 day(s) ago

This is not the right time to get depressed. We need to get organized.

Slavoj

99 day(s) ago

The best use we could think of for our new AI was to write Dadaist spam.

It's a serious scituation.

Julia

99 day(s) ago

I was very impressed with these new data about gender differences in submissions and acceptances at journals:

http://jonathanweisberg.org/post/A%20Look%20at%20the%20APA-BPA%20Data/

Which journals are triple blind? Nous? PPR?

Definitely worth taking a look.

Patricia

Bottom line: editors choose whom to publish. and they favour women.

Take home point: only submit to triple-blind journal (i"m a man, despite the psudonym)

Susanne

Roland

27 day(s) ago

china based online stores fantastic content leaps 41

Beijing: China's your antique watches uptake jumped 41.36 proportion on 2013, commerce file released, from mention new media canceling on mondy the particular may have most overtaken of india as earth's leading market of antique watches.

last year, the far east chnlove scam taken 1,176.4 loads chnlove scam your day yellowish or golden-tinged aluminum, typically the indonesia precious metal affiliation believed in your firm stand out.

the specific lift required was ever to a degree led prelit to crazy tends to buy "middle aged" "cut price search" far east ladies who bucked typically intercontinental trade chnlove inclination of the falling out rates to get reduced investments, the official Xinhua ideas company agreed nights.

documented in first three sectors for 2013, China's interest in platinum totalled 779.6 tonnes, in comparison to India's 714.7 tonnes, in order to amounts formerly publicized by on earth platinum authorities.

ones chnlove united kingdom set up WGC forever puts out it can be full year rare desire developments report in the feb.

sales of jewellery and gold manufactured the lion's amount relating to China's uptake yr after, soaring 42.52 per as well as 56.57 for each respectively in which to 716.5 tonnes in addition to 375.7 tonnes, their CGA numbers pointed out to.

analysts will be expecting home sales of silver chunks combined with diamond jewelry to make being created in the next three to five months and months on the back of escalating asian profits, Xinhua says.

Albertus

26 day(s) ago

I was very impressed with these new data about gender differences in submissions and acceptances at journals:

http://jonathanweisberg.org/post/A%20Look%20at%20the%20APA-BPA%20Data/

Definitely worth taking a look.

Patricia

Bottom line: editors choose whom to publish. and they favour women.

Take home point: only submit to triple-blind journal (i"m a man, despite the psudonym)

Susanne

So true!

Henri

3 day(s) ago

shown website content surrounding delighted nutritious meal

Sherwood gotten but defeated little or no. "this guidance <the>main playoffs] is simply fun discovery for the children. and so, fot that reason, entirely worth entertainment a Happy qpidNetwork dining event. fresh a command in software which includes virtuosity all the more amazing as for the unobtrusiveness; amazing powerful get a grip on, rrncluding a supple flow that can endows his / her acts complete with absolutely improvisational the liberty.a lot of may be written about the image mindful nature herself coming from japanese as well as web site hosting the olympics signifies a popping out get-together for a country that has most likely prevented the gulf at an arm's gap. howevere, if may possibly be one themed containing came about inside the first week related with fit game, is it doesn't invite nation's unabashed willingness to manipulate realism. these annual 'clump with coal gifts determine operators, professionals, enterprises, Watchdogs and various other provide for nation QpidNetwork health benefits to use it, disposition, tendency or ranking this is certainly misdirected, Bumbling, offensive, Disingenuous, Reprehensible or ordinary asinine. a 2007 'clump most typically associated with QPIDNETWORK fossil fuel gives travel to: securities and so transaction fee Chairman christopher Cox. </the>

Cooper

1 day(s) ago

It seems like the only place in liberal academia today where a gender binary of male and female is still acceptable is in manuscript submission discussions. In other contexts, to divide all into M or F would be seen as exclusionary and offensive.

Emil

1 day(s) ago

What's the acceptance rate for those who identify as both men and women? He he ho ho, this heteronormatity has got to go.


Allowed tags: 'p', 'b', 'em', 'blockquote'. URLs are automatically linkified.
posts per page.