philosophy meta-forum

What's the turn around time at [insert journal] like these days?

Luigi

18 day(s) ago

I'll start. How quick is Analysis these days?

Kang

18 day(s) ago

1-2 months

Curt

18 day(s) ago

Analysis used to desk reject the majority of submissions, but now they seem to be sending more papers out to reviewers, which increases the average turn around time a bit. It's also worth mentioning that since the change in policy, Analysis has taken a turn for the worst in terms of average article quality.

Justus

18 day(s) ago

All my submissions to Analysis have been rejected after almost exactly one month (with comments).

How about... AJP?

Luigi

18 day(s) ago

I was recently rejected after ~2.5 months at AJP, and received a very thorough report.

Graham

18 day(s) ago

Synthese?

(Also: great thread!)

Yehuda

18 day(s) ago

I always hear back exactly three months after submitting to Noûs or PPR in the initial round and within six weeks in subsequent rounds.

Fujiwara

14 day(s) ago

Submitted to Ancient Philosophy in early June. I didnt hear anything from them

Naomi

3 day(s) ago

Submitted to Archiv over 5 months ago. Still waiting.

Rosa

3 day(s) ago

How could a forum structured like this possibly supply that information? You would need data, from which to make statistical inferences. Slightly differently, do you think it is rational to make a decision on where to submit based upon the anecdotes (and conjecture) supplied here?

I'll start.

How quick is Analysis these days?

Luigi

Rosa

3 day(s) ago

This is, of course, more useful - at least as a stage for identifying reasons for action: https://airtable.com/shrWKotYTw0ezNN4N/tbl9E479DxjlJf2zJ


Allowed tags: 'p', 'b', 'em', 'blockquote'. URLs are automatically linkified.
posts per page.